Gear Review: Frying Pans
by Jim Reynolds
Co. H, 4th U.S. Infantry, Sykes Regulars

    As anyone who has looked for one knows, finding a really period correct frying pan can be quite the challenge. While the canteen half has its uses, it also has its drawbacks such as finding a proper stick that will hold it and the instability of the round shape. Some pans currently sold at many sutlers really aren’t period correct or require modification to make them appear more correct. The consensus on period pans being one of sheet steel rather than cast iron and a handle riveted separately on the pan rather than cast into it.

    Recently there was a thread on the Authentic Campaigner forum asking about an authentic fry pan. Several posters mentioned a Frank Ellis as making good ones. Being a reenactor shopaholic, I sent him a short note asking for further information about his products. He promptly replied with a post card listing his sizes and prices and I decided to order his 7 inch model. It arrived reasonably soon in the mail and I was immediately impressed by its light-weight and forged handle. The prices are a tad high but still within range of high quality reenactor gear. I tried a few test drives on the kitchen stove and had to remind myself that thin sheet steel is really best left for the campfire where burning things is part of the fun. A trip through the dishwasher left a little bit of rust which was quickly dispatched with a thin coat of olive oil on all the surfaces.

    Those who attended the Pamplin Park event may have seen my fry pan on Saturday morning as I fried up a bunch of bacon for everybody. The seven inch pan which is about two inches deep is a perfect size for individual cooking and could easily handle frying rations for a typical mess. One of the larger models would be better for more than that. It also easily fits into a haversack and would make a nice plate-substitute/cooking implement for a campaigner event. Not that I’m suggesting everyone start carrying a fry pan, but if you happen to be in the market for one, I can recommend Mr. Ellis’.

Ordering info:
Frank Ellis
3031 Possum Trot Rd.
Greenbrier, TN 37073-5741

7” skillet $25.75 9” skillet $27.75 11” skillet $30.75 prices include postage.

    Home : About : Gallery : Events : Recruiting : Equipment : Instruction : Resources : Forum