Each debater has added to his research over the previous year.
We look forward to cogent discussions on other relevant battles, especially for the 1862 period.
I'd especially like to see some discussion on Perryville in general, and specifically on the series of events that led to untrained, poorly armed Ohio troops being sacrificed, while other Federal troops were held in reserve and never used. Also discuss water quality and volume required with both armies looking for water. Doctor's Creek ain't that big.