I just wanted to know anyone's oppinion on the enlisted slouch hat from Blockade Runner. Is the design authentic?
Tkessen
I just wanted to know anyone's oppinion on the enlisted slouch hat from Blockade Runner. Is the design authentic?
Tkessen
"What? Men dodging this way for single bullets? What will you do when they open fire along the whole line? I am ashamed of you. They couldn't hit an elephant at this distance..." -Gen. John Sedgwick- His last words before being killed by a sniper at the Battle of Spotsylvania.
I have yet to hear anyone sing praises about the finished product. To be fair, I've not heard anyone dump on it either. However, if it looks the same in pictures as the better venders but it costs way less, it's bound to have flaws. You may not be able to tell the difference until after it has suffered through its first, drenching, Baptist rain while out on campaign. The cheap hats go soft and need viagra. The quality ones don't.
Spend the bucks for a quality hat, and you won't regret it later.
Silas Tackitt
"While the original battle [Gettysburg] may arguably be considered the epicenter of the history of the war, the GAC reenactment is not the epicenter of the hobby. To confuse or equate the two is unfortunate. - Bernard Biederman, 6 July 2012
"Authenticity conflicts occur when reenactors from one end of the spectrum attend events at the other end of the spectrum then try to impose their own standards instead of event standards."
I've been to the store in Bell Buckle and seen the hats close up. They run the gamut from floppy felt blanks that you can deck out to a few that are getting close to the better hat vendors on the market. I've never purchased a hat from them. My hat businees has gone to Kiev Thomason, Nick Sekela, Tim Bender, and Tim Allen.
The folks at the Blockade Runner store could probably answer any question that you have more in depth. The employees there have been nice as can be everytime I stop for random items. Do a search online for their website.
Hope this helps too.
I have one of the Fall Creek Dirty Billy beehives without the lining and I'm really happy with it, for what its worth.
John E Rys
5th Texas Co A - NE Ohio
Medich Battalion
1ST NC Lt Arty - Reilly's Battery
"My hat businees has gone to Kiev Thomason, Nick Sekela, Tim Bender, and Tim Allen."
Stick with these above vendors and you will be much better off, promise.
Justin Morris
Independent Rifles
The Gun Deck Boys
Sir:
IMHO, your hat can and will, make or break your impression. I would advise to spend the couple extra bucks and get a good one. It will last a you a long time and probably become your signature look. I can only speak from personal experience to some of the makers mentioned. I had one of Dirty Billy's Economical hats from Fall Creek but I returned it immediately. However, Dirty Billy's best quality hats are top shelf. Hard to find a better hat than a Tim Bender and NJ Sekela produces some great hats as well. Additionally, I have had excellent luck with Clearwater Hats. Although B.R. has excellent items at decent prices, some items are, well, economical. I wont say anything bad about B.R. since I have not personally had one of their hats. I have (and still do) had other products from B.R. and they do have very good customer service in my experience.
However, again I reinterate, your hat is so very noticable. A good one is, well, the best first impression. A less than correct bean cover is well, just that. General public may not be aware but trust me, your pards will be. Just my couple of pennies in the pile.....
REspectfully,
Last edited by harley_davis; 01-13-2011 at 04:36 PM.
Harley
5th Minnesota Regt. Vol. Infy.,Co. C
1st South Carolina Volunteers, Co. H
New Ulm Battery
Old West Regulators - Minnesota
"I love my wife so much, I almost told her the other day!!" Old Norwegian
http://fifthminnesotacompanyc.webs.com/
Most any hat that didn't start out as a "Cowboy Hat" will have a leg up on those that did. I get pretty tired of seeing beat up cowboy hats being passed off as slouch hats. I see 'em at every event. Even some that still have the wire or plastic cord sewn in around the edge of the brim. You can pick them out because the brims look like a potato chip.
Trouble with any hat is that it starts out by being brand new. Showing up on the field with a perfectly new and shiny hat sticks out. They remind me of the way Larson drew the cowboys in his famous cartoons. Get it wet, dust it up, reshape it, sweat in it. Pretty soon it will pass as a durn nice hat.
Harley Davis, I too bought a Fall Creek Dirty Billie hat, but I didn't return it. I did to it what I mentioned above and it's really beginning to be my favorite hat for sunny days.
Harry
Member 5th Texas Co. A/1st NC Artillery. Disabled Viet Nam veteran, 1970. I was so much older then, I'm younger than that now! Read my column in "Camp Chase Gazette".
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S4UcaLHaabY
Tkessen,
just spend the $110 or so with Tim Bender and you will not have a better experience with customer service, time, and product. It will last. Period.
Justin Morris
Independent Rifles
The Gun Deck Boys
I have long advocated that you need to have a good hat, that reenactors have such a shoe fetish yet ignore some of the worst travesties to be on prominent display on their heads has always amazed me. Yet that said, look at the photos and you will see that cheap hats were worn, some horrible hillbilly ones at that, also at some point every hat was new and with proper care could look new for some time especially if it was a good quality hat to start with, applied dirt looks fake. Let your hat age with use and take care of it as it does and it will look better than one that costs double the amount with mud smeared on in an "artful" manner.
Tom Bramlette
Glad you asked that question! It is vital to the core of the hobby!
Fill that rusty canteen with apple cider vinegar, cork it, and leave it in the back of a cool, dark, closet for 16 weeks. That will fix everything.
Glad to be of service!
1. All guns are always loaded.
2. Never point at anything you are not willing to kill.
3. Keep your finger off the trigger until your sights are on target.
4. Be sure of your target and what is beyond it.
-Jeff Cooper
Bookmarks